Vintage Post: I’ve Been Duped - And So Have You!

Posted in Social Commentary on August 29th, 2007 by Erin Dietrich

Oh, what kind of fool am I? I found myself outraged and intrigued last week by the homes and energy consumption of President Bush and former Vice-President Al Gore. In fact, I cared enough to research and write a post about it. Click here to read last week’s post “President Bush, In the Closet? Al Gore a Hypocrite?”. Now I’ve realized that not only was I missing the big picture this whole time, I’ve also been drastically underestimating the players – a couple of shifty politicians. Worse yet, if I’m right, not only have I been duped - so have you!

One of our readers forwarded me the link to “The Great Global Warming Swindle”, a documentary challenging human’s responsibility for climate change. Click here to watch the film. For those not fluent with the climate change debate (also referred to as global warming), it is widely believed that the rise in carbon dioxide emissions is one of the largest contributors to our changing climate. Carbon dioxide is emitted when we do things such as produce electricity from coal, drive and make plastic. “The Great Global Warming Swindle” never asserts climate change is not occurring; rather it convincingly argues that a link does not exist between climate change and carbon emissions. Thus, the role we can play in stopping or reversing climate change is radically less than popular propaganda would have us believe.

Since Al Gore appears to understand the “climate crisis” so well, I’d argue it’s highly probable that he is aware of this data and believes it. This explains why he has done so little to personally to reduce his “carbon footprint”, especially in relation to the comforts of home (and a two year $30,000 gas and electric bill and a pool buys you comforts!). Does the persona of environmental crusader promise him enough notoriety (and potentially a second bid at the White House) that he is unwilling to “out” the true facts, and the potentially even scarier truth, that personal responsibility isn’t enough to reverse the impending climate changes? If so, what does this say about Al Gore the man?

Maybe President Bush isn’t as dim as he’s been publicly portrayed, especially on the subject of climate change. Say he also believes that carbon dioxide emissions are not linked to a changing climate and is therefore equally unconcerned. So why his sustainable home? I’d imagine in his role as President of the United States he is privy to a lot of information that the rest of us aren’t; such as doomsday scenarios. There are dwindling resources worldwide and gaps in our country’s internal and external security as well as disaster planning and readiness. What better place to be if our country’s infrastructure collapses than at home secluded on hundreds of acres with animal herds, vast amounts of security (or at least guns) and sustainable water and energy supplies. Makes you wonder, just what DOES he know?

If carbon dioxide emissions aren’t responsible for climate change, it sheds some light on the seemingly contradictory private versus public behavior of both Al Gore and President Bush. It also raises some very scary questions, questions I’m almost too afraid to ask. What aren’t they telling us? And why?


Related Posts:
President Bush, In the Closet? Al Gore, A Hypocrite?

Share this article with others: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Ma.gnolia
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Technorati

11 Responses to “Vintage Post: I’ve Been Duped - And So Have You!”

  1. Liara Covert Says:

    When it comes right down to the crux, its hard to know what someone else’s perception of the truth really is. You can only evolve to shape your own views. Critical thinking is a wonderful skill which encourages us to take everything we perceive with more than a grain of salt. After all, each person has a vested interest in whatever they say and do, even if its unconscious. What you choose to see is the illusion you create for yourself.

  2. Dan Says:

    Erin, good for you for exposing the hypocrisy of BOTH sides. Often Democrats only point to the wrongs of Republicans and make excuses for their own behavior. Republicans point to the wrongs of the Democrats, and make excuses for their own.

    They’re ALL rascals. I don’t trust ANY of them. Whenever someone with a political agenda starts talking politics, my BS detector starts beeping. So, for instance, I distrust documentaries about gun control by Michael Moore as much as I distrust them by the NRA. Hugs!

  3. Erin Says:

    Liara, I agree. When it comes to hard science though it can be hard to know what to believe. Critical thinking is a great skill, but hard when one of the few ways to definitively wade through the muck is to do the research oneself. I have gone out with determination to figure out many things (such as climate change) and come back more confused than when I started. Ugh.

    Dan, those darn politicians, huh? How many politicians does it take to change a light bulb?

  4. Liara Covert Says:

    Hi Erin,
    It makes sense to be a critical thinker and no to take everything at face value. Its not possible to redo all the research out there. You have to learn to trust your instincts.

  5. Mark Says:

    It does make it really difficult to know what to do, and to know what lifestyle changes are necessary, and which are unnecessarily restrictive.

  6. Erin Says:

    Mark, I completely agree. Trying to live an “environmentally conscious” lifestyle is not always easy - nor fun. What if none of it really matters to the extent we thought? Would you still avoid using your air conditioner? Would you start driving more? Would you stop eating local food? Living against the norm is hard, and especially if it doesn’t matter…

  7. Cis Says:

    Dont’ forget to watch Scam of the “Great Global Warming Swindle” as well.

  8. Cis Says:

    or make that http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-1656640542976216573

  9. Jenny Says:

    Hey - thanks Cis!

  10. Erin Says:

    Oh boy, it’s deeper than I thought! I’ll watch it tonight as I wait for my head to explode. Cis, what do you think of the whole thing?

  11. Cis Says:

    Well, as always, too much information is disinformation. I’ve never seen The Inconvenient Truth, but in both documentaries, name dropping seems one very important factor for credibility and besides that we all know it’s very easy to give whatever twist to numbers and information in this type of medium.

    I guess that respect towards nature and people is always a good thing, it makes you even feel better as a person so why not, give a little, take a little… (It’s great fun to ride a bike for instance :)

Leave a Reply